top of page
DCG_1c_Reversed_RGB.jpg
I'm Interested in...
Services & Software
Events & Resources
Company

Learn how DCG's online analytical solutions can help bring clarity to the complex.

DCG Insights

Stay up to date on the latest from DCG

Do Loss Trades Create Value... or Just Move Earnings Recognition?

Writer: DCG
DCG
3 days ago
2 min read

Updated: 3 hours ago

The DCG advisory consulting team starts every week with an internal discussion of market trends, regulatory developments, and the real experiences of our bank and credit union clients. Here are the notes from this week’s Monday Morning Meeting.


Deposits360°® Monthly Industry Review
Check out the meeting notes from previous weeks.


Do you have a question?


As year-end approaches, financial institutions are once again being presented with ‘opportunities’ to restructure their investment portfolios by selling securities at a loss and reinvesting the proceeds at higher yields. The pitch can be compelling: Recognize the loss today, improve future earnings, and potentially recover that loss through higher investment income over a relatively short period. Loss trades do not create economic value; they simply change when earnings are recognized.

This week's Monday morning discussion reiterated DCG’s long-held belief that these transactions deserve considerably more scrutiny than a simple payback calculation.

Consider the mechanics of a loss trade. An institution sells a security, realizes a loss, and receives cash. It then reinvests those proceeds into another asset offering a higher yield. These are two distinct decisions.

The sale itself does not create the higher future earnings (in fact, when factoring in transaction costs, it does the opposite). The decision about what to purchase next does. And that replacement asset may introduce additional duration, credit, liquidity, or optionality risk. A transaction that appears attractive because of a short payback period may look very different when those risks, transaction costs, and the impact on capital are fully considered.

What assumptions are producing a short payback? Is the institution accepting additional credit risk? Extending duration? Sacrificing liquidity? Increasing leverage? And what happens if/when the balance sheet changes before the projected payback is achieved (these transactions are rarely tracked to determine the accuracy of the ‘payback period’)?

If the objective is to generate additional future income, why must the institution first recognize a loss? There are many other (and likely preferable) funding options to add good assets to a balance sheet without having to sell anything!

Loss trades are not inherently wrong. There may be legitimate reasons to restructure an investment portfolio. But those decisions should begin with the institution's overall balance sheet objectives, not a desire to improve next year's reported earnings. A higher reported yield is not the same thing as increased value.

What are others seeing?

For more insights from Darling Consulting Group, click here.


© 2026 Darling Consulting Group, Inc.

bottom of page